What I look for that a pitch won’t show you

A lot of what decides an agency relationship happens after the pitch. These are the things I check before you sign.

Who does the work

The people in the pitch and the people on your account aren’t always the same. Meet the team that will do it, and ask whether they’ve seen what sales is promising you.

Whether they get curious

A good agency asks about your economics and your competitors before it recommends tactics.

Claims you can check

Comparable work, what the agency’s part in it actually was, and references you can call.

What you’ll own

Accounts, analytics and data in your name, so changing agencies later doesn’t mean starting over.

How they price

What drives the number, what’s excluded, and what more money would actually buy.

How they report

What they measure, how often, and whether it ties back to revenue rather than activity.

How a search usually runs

A search usually runs a few weeks to a couple of months, set by the size of the spend and how many channels the agency will run. From you, it usually takes a kickoff session on the brief, time with the finalists, and a decision meeting.

  • The brief and the criteria

    What you’re hiring for, the budget you can commit, and what would make it worth it. We agree on the criteria in writing before any proposal arrives, so the goalposts can’t move once we see who’s bidding.

  • The shortlist and the pitches

    A short list of firms whose relevant work you can see, each with my reasons. Every finalist answers the same questions, and I push on the answers until they’re clear.

  • The decision and the start

    My recommendation shows its reasons against the criteria, so you can check my thinking. Once you choose, I can stay on your side to judge the work as it starts, or step back.

The conflict, handled up front

I founded a marketing agency, and at times I have referral or partner arrangements with others, so you should ask whether I’ll steer you. I only put firms on the list that I think fit your situation. If I’d benefit in any way from one of them, I say so in writing on the shortlist itself, next to my reasons, and it’s measured against the same criteria as everyone else.

Leaving an agency

If it’s time to move on, I help you do it without losing your accounts or your history: who owns what, what the contract says about notice, how to keep things running in between, and vetting and onboarding whoever comes next.

What it costs

If finding your next agency is why you’re bringing me in, the search is the engagement, not an extra fee. We scope what it covers up front, whether that’s sourcing firms from scratch or joining once you already have a shortlist. Leaving an agency often takes more attention than a normal month, so we agree up front whether it fits the time you’ve reserved or gets scoped on its own.

8 to 16 hours a month

From $3,000

a month · about 2 to 4 hours a week

Decision support on your highest-stakes calls

32 to 48 hours a month

$8,000 to $12,000+

a month · about 8 to 12 hours a week

I own a defined part of your marketing, including the agencies working on it

48 to 80 hours a month

$12,000 to $18,000+

a month · about 12 to 20 hours a week

Agency decisions across several companies under one owner or fund

Terms run 3, 6 or 12 months, at the same monthly fee. We agree on the fee before we start, and your price is locked for the term. Agency fees, tools, ad spend and any hands-on work are separate.

Not ready to commit? A review of your current agency, or of proposals you already have, can be scoped on its own, and it can be done quietly, from the reports and access you already have. If it leads to a monthly engagement, we pick up from what it found rather than starting over.

What’s separate

  • Agency fees, paid to the agency
  • Tools and ad spend
  • Any hands-on work

Each is scoped and priced before it starts.

Terms

Terms run 3, 6 or 12 months, at the same monthly fee. I keep a limited number of clients, so the term is how long I hold my time for you. The first month’s fee is paid before we start, and after that I bill on the first of each month for the month ahead.

Every term, including twelve months, runs its full length and renews for the same length unless either of us says otherwise before the last month of the term starts.

Full details are on Work With Me.

How the hours work. The hours are an average across the term, not a cap in any one month. The first month is the busiest, and some months run lighter. They’re reserved for you, not billed by the minute or banked from month to month.

The kind of companies I advise

TDI Packsys website homepage

Food inspection equipment · since 2021

TDI Packsys

An equipment maker competing against industry giants. TDI says more than 90% of its sales start on the website.

My role. I set a research-first strategy and guided my team from the rebuilt site into SEO, paid search and content. The relationship has since grown into strategic advisory.

  • 600% growth in qualified organic traffic since 2021, with organic now matching paid in lead volume.
  • On ChatGPT’s shortlist, alongside the industry giants, when a poultry processor asks about x-ray bone detection (November 2026).

Read the full case study

Focus Solutions website homepage

Healthcare IT · since 2025

Focus Solutions

A healthcare IT company that had built something no competitor offered, with no ten-second way to say it.

My role. I led the positioning and guided my team through everything built on it: identity, sales tools, content, video and trade shows, all from one strategy. Today I work directly with their board on go-to-market.

  • “The best he’s ever seen.” A leadership advisor who had worked with six other agencies on brand work.
  • Repositioned from “another MSP” to a category of one, with a framework their sales team still uses with prospects.

Read the full case study

laptop and camera with a headphone

Your side of an agency search

These are the parts of a search that decide whether it ends well.

Is it the agency, or is it us?

If you already have an agency, that’s the first question. If the agency isn’t setting clear expectations and review dates, it might be the agency. If those conversations are happening and the plan keeps getting blown up on your side, it might be you. Sometimes the right answer is keeping the agency you have with a better brief.

The specialist problem

A few of the companies I’ve led marketing for hired me partly to be their voice with their own vendors, sometimes after my own agency told them it wasn’t the right fit for the work. One of those vendors was a paid-search specialist. They knew the tools cold, and they were optimizing beautifully toward numbers that didn’t connect closely enough to what the business needed. Before I came in, nobody on the client’s side could push back in the specialist’s language, and that was part of what I was brought in to do. Specialists are worth hiring. Somebody owner-minded still has to steer them.

Start with your own numbers

Work out what a new customer is worth, what you could afford to spend to win one, and what you’re spending now. Walk in with those numbers and you have something to measure an agency against. Walk in without them and the agency ends up setting the target for you.

Do you need an agency at all?

If the work is one narrow specialty, a specialist may be better and cheaper. If marketing is central to how you grow and steady in volume, an in-house hire with outside help might serve you better. When you hire in-house, be careful who screens the candidates. I’ve seen good companies make bad marketing hires because the wrong person did the screening.

After the hire

The first months are when expectations either get set or drift. Agree up front how you’ll work together: approvals, reporting, review dates, and what you keep if you part ways. If I stay on, my job is to judge the work against what was promised and keep the agency pointed at the company’s goals. For the step-by-step method, how to choose a marketing agency covers it in detail.

I’m based in Houston and work with companies across the U.S.

Start with a conversation

Send me a few sentences about what you’re hiring for, or what isn’t working with the agency you have. I’ll reply within one business day, and if there’s a fit, we’ll set up a free scoping call.

Start a conversation

Rodney Warner, seated, in a flat cap and dark t-shirt

Rodney Warner

Marketing and business advisor to owners and leadership teams. Based in Houston, working nationwide.

Talk it through with me

Bring the decision you’re stuck on. We’ll work out whether you need advice, an agency, or neither.

Start a conversation

Free scoping call. Reply within one business day.

Questions about an agency search

How long does a search take?

A few weeks to a couple of months, set by the size of the spend and how many channels the agency will run.

The agency’s fees, paid to the agency. Work With Me has the terms.